Sitting Long Enough Cancels The Beneficial Effects of Exercise

0 0
Read Time:3 Minute, 48 Second

It’s not too difficult to imagine this scenario in the tech and service-sector-heavy American economy.

A working individual wakes up, sits down to have breakfast, sits down in their car to drive 20-60 minutes to an office, wherein they sit for four hours, stand up to go to a lunch break, sit down for a 30-minute lunch break, return to their office and sit down until the working day ends at 4-5 PM whereby they sit in their car on the way home, sit at the dinner table, and sit in front of the television or on a comfy chair for some reading.

Modern physiology is discovering that all this sitting adds up, and that at a certain point of around 13 hours of sitting time, or less than 4,000 steps taken per day, even if this individual had managed to fit a 60-minute run into their busy day, it would be met with a biological ‘resistance to exercise’ and the benefits it brings to metabolic health.

With exercise, as is normally the case, governmental health guidelines recommend the bare minimum amount: that an individual should obtain 150 minutes of moderate exercise per week to stave off conditions like obesity, cardiovascular disease, and diabetes. That is essentially two 60-minute runs per week plus a small jog extra, which is exactly how much exercise was used in the discussed 2019 study in the Journal of Applied Physiology.

The study compared results with the recommended exercise amounts suggested by organizations like the American CDC, the World Health Organization, The National Institute of Health, and the Mayo Clinic.

It’s all about movement

American functional medicine practitioner Chris Kresser, MD, recently wrote about this problem “that even marathon runners in training that are mostly sedentary outside of their exercise periods are at an increased risk of disease and early death,” underlying the significance of cutting down sitting times.

It’s quite clearly known through meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials that exercise does improve measures of postprandial (as in post-meal consumption) glycemia, insulin responses, and circulating fat in the bloodstream. Another meta-analysis of over 1 million patients with follow-up times between 2-18 years which looked at all-cause mortality correlated with sitting and exercise times found that moderate exercise, if done daily, suppresses the risk factor of prolonged sitting regardless of the amount of hours spent sitting.

However, if those periods of prolonged sitting stretch out between days, it is the time spent exercising that is suppressed, regardless of its intensity.

The trial found that after 3 days of sitting 13 hours a day and taking less than 4,000 steps, a fourth day exactly the same, or with a 60-minute run at 60% maximum heart rate, created no noticeable difference, and that the exercising did nothing to improve metabolic health conditions. This is so-called exercise resistance, which the study, limited in its scope, could not expound upon beyond merely hypothesizing.

Exercise, the authors write, increases the production and circulation of molecules in the blood that clear away macronutrients, such as glucose transporter proteins like GLUT4, which clear away carbs and sugars, or lipoprotein lipase which clears triglycerides. The relative lack of these markers in the blood of the sedentary individuals could mean that something is dampening this key function of exercise.

“This may indicate that someone who sits throughout the week and chooses to exercise on the weekend (e.g., the “weekend jogger”) may not derive the full health benefits of the exercise,” they write.

Kresser suggests an aim for walking about 10,000 steps a day and standing for about half of the day, as well as modifying daily habits to increase walking behavior or remove sitting behavior such as buying a standing or treadmill desk, parking a mile from the office and walking there, using the stairs instead of the elevator, or going on walking lunches/meetings. WaL

Happy
Happy
0 %
Sad
Sad
0 %
Excited
Excited
0 %
Sleepy
Sleepy
0 %
Angry
Angry
0 %
Surprise
Surprise
0 %

The Sunday Catchup provides all the week's stories, so you never start the week uninformed

Average Rating

5 Star
0%
4 Star
0%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
0%

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *